The Yemima Method: An Israeli Psychological-Spiritual Approach

I dedicate this essay to my friend Dr. Tsippi Kauffman z”l, who passed away in the course of its writing. A wonderful educator, academic, and spiritual force, her work lives on after her. I am happy that, through this article, more people will be able to benefit from her sensitive insights and brilliant scholarship.

Readers of Lehrhaus have been treated recently to articles about Rav Shagar and Rav Froman. That these fresh and exceptional thinkers sprang up on Israeli soil is, I would like to think, not mere coincidence. We declare energetically in synagogue, “For from Zion shall emerge the Torah.” While clearly much Torah emerged not from Zion, it seems – and has been compellingly argued¹ – that in Israel, a unique and profound type of Jewish spirituality may flourish in a way impossible in constricted exilic living.

We have returned to our native soil with the purpose of (re)creating not only a physical homeland but also a spiritual center, an incubator for new and diverse Hebrew approaches. Let us note, too, that both aforementioned thinkers are characterized not only by depth but also by breadth. The Torah from Zion, far from being more localised and more nationalistic as we might expect, seems, perhaps as a result of us “breathing more freely” in our own Land, paradoxically capable of comfortably embracing broader swathes of human living i.e. being more universal in nature. Whether this really is so would require an examination of many other thinkers, and a larger discussion. What I’d like to do here is to add into the mix another uniquely Jewish-Israeli spiritual phenomenon, similarly homegrown yet with wide-ranging appeal. Though slightly off the radar for most Lehrhaus readers, it’s one I’ve personally encountered and find fascinating. 

To introduce the topic, let me share that along with a deep suspicion of charismatic figures, I recognize the value of having a good teacher in one’s life. At its deeply Hasidic apotheosis, this latter side of me yearns to have someone to call “rebbe,” with all the baggage that that word brings. I have, in fact, been fortunate to have had several people to call my “rebbe” so far; but, like the protagonist in the movie Good Will Hunting, many of my heroes are dead. Of these, two recent and prominent ones are women, who passed away in 1997 and 1999.² The first is Nehama Leibowitz (1905-1997). After ten years spent writing and immersing in her biography and her Torah,³ I presume I can call her my rebbe; though both her modesty and also her dyed-in-the-wool Yekkeness means that undoubtedly she would rather I dance the horah on her grave than call her by that title. 

However, I truly learned what having a rebbe is from Yemima Avital (1929-1999). Very little is known about this special individual’s biography.⁴ Born in Casablanca, Morocco in 1929 to a family of kabbalists, and religiously observant, Yemima made aliyah at age 20 to Be’er Sheva, married, and then completed Bachelor’s and Masters’ degrees in French literature and psychology. She subsequently moved to Tel Aviv where she studied psychology at Tel Aviv University and began healing treatments in her house, along with teaching a new approach in emotional management to groups of students. In 1987, she founded Machon Ma’ayan in Herzliya to disseminate her therapeutic teachings, which coalesced into a method that officially goes under the title Hashivah hakaratit, “Cognitive/Awareness Thinking”, and unofficially Shitat Yemima, “The Yemima method.”⁵

Yemima was not your run-of-the-mill teacher. She viewed herself as a channel for heavenly teachings that descended through her; her language was, indeed, odd and poetic, and phrased in not entirely comprehensible Hebrew. She taught while covered in white scarves, sitting at first behind a curtain and then actually a full story above her students. This was so that the students’ attention would be focused on her message and not on her, to prevent the cult of personality from developing;⁶ and also because she claimed to be able to “see” things about her students, which she found distracting when in their proximity.⁷ People reported that she told them things about themselves that she could not have known, and she purportedly healed people of terminal diseases.⁸ 

And yet her actual topics were not mystical at all, but rather focused on the basic building blocks of how a person functions emotionally, and how this functioning can be improved, for greater happiness, wellbeing, and centeredness.

If asked what were her influences, I would have to say that I do not precisely know what these were, and I have not come across anyone listing them. If indeed she was channeling wisdom from a place beyond, then this obviates the need to speak about influences. But if forced to hazard a guess, apart from heavenly inspiration, I’d assume both psychological knowledge (from her studies) and Jewish knowledge (from her background). To compare and contrast her method with other psychological methods (such as cognitive-behavioural therapy, CBT) is beyond the scope of this article. Suffice it to quote one psychologist very familiar with her work, who notes that Yemima’s emphasis on one’s responsibility to the collective separates her from the discipline of psychology: “According to Yemima, you are obligated to fix your soul. It’s not a luxury, because all of Israel is responsible one for the other.”⁹

Jewish ideas play a significant role in Yemima’s work. On the one hand, they are embedded in her teachings only sporadically: a few verses on the role of men or women, on loving your fellow as yourself, or on the essential meaning of Jewish holidays.¹⁰ The sessions with her could not be described as shiurim or Torah classes in the classic sense. As I’ve already mentioned, once her odd language was decoded, her lessons would be discovered to be instructions for conscious self-work and psychological balance, containing unique terminology and catchphrases. Yet her acolytes would categorically claim that her system was connected to Jewish spirituality and Torah, or even revealed the inner meaning of the Torah to this generation. One student explains: “You can study ‘Yemima’ only in order to be calmer and happier and you do not necessarily touch spirituality or religion. But from the beginning, there are very specific and deep connections to Jewish spirituality hidden in the teachings, which one can understand only in subsequent stages.”¹¹ Indeed, a significant number of students became baalei teshuvah through Yemima.¹²

I will return to this topic soon. First, though, I’ll bring some examples of her terminology to give a sense of her approach. One key term is “diyuk” (precision), meaning the precise action required in or by the moment. Taking into account the entire picture, and separating yourself as far as possible from your baggage, you arrive at the understanding of what is the most correct or highest course of action to take. 

Of particular interest to me was the fact that while this action will sometimes involve giving to others, the question the student is encouraged to consider from the outset is “What is precise and right for me?”, and often to prioritize her own needs.¹³ Though this might seem at first blush to encourage selfishness – and indeed initially seemed so to me – in fact, Yemima was helping people (and religious women in particular¹⁴) to rebalance a socialised tendency to put others first that leaves them drained and dysfunctional. Amongst a number of mottos and pithy maxims that she coined was the saying: “I need to give to myself, in order to give to others,” echoing Hillel’s statements in Pirkei Avot.¹⁵ We learn how to give to others by learning how to how to give to ourselves; and giving to ourselves, when this is done with diyuk, can positively influence others around us.¹⁶ Thus the intent was not to boost self-absorption; far from it.¹⁷ For myself I can say that it was only when studying the Yemima method that I first discovered that it was not only legitimate but also crucial to attend to my own needs – a lesson that laid the foundations for my life and strengthened me immeasurably. 

Yemima employed a number of other terms and concepts relating to emotional functioning, including: omess (literally “(over)load”, referring to emotional baggage and unconscious defense mechanisms from childhood); tihum ve-hafradah (creating boundaries and separation from the baggage); hakarah pe’ilah (active awareness); and regesh le-kiyumi (positive feelings towards my own existence). Further terms she used included identifying, self-acceptance, coming close to oneself, not becoming entangled with others, and many more, repeating themselves in myriad ways throughout the lessons. Her general approach was that the human psychology is fundamentally positive.¹⁸ She did not encourage picking at childhood wounds, but rather contemplating negative emotions as they arose in real time.¹⁹

Yemima often commented on the relationships between her students and their parents and how pain from those early relationships should not be carried over into the present day. She directed her students to separate between negative behavior acquired through childhood omess and mahoot, the real essence of the human being which is of a good nature and well-constructed.²⁰ “The main purpose of her theory,” notes scholar Tsippi Kauffman, “is quite prosaic: to be able to listen and respond calmly to everyone who turns to us, to be able to stay emotionally balanced in the face of every event in life.”²¹ This is done by creating a separation between the omess and the aware observing self, which can then, in the space created, expand into wellbeing, good, and self love. This is what a person’s genuine self looks like, when finally free of omess.²² One practitioner, a clinical psychologist, reported: “The baseline of my life rose to a higher level. I don’t fall down as much. I am a much happier person. I don’t hear this constant disturbing buzz of pain and bitterness that I did before I started.”²³

Yemima’s teaching was given over in halakim, “portions”;²⁴ the word “portion” indeed subsequently became the official name for any Yemima teaching. The portions were like “therapeutic conversations” addressed in second or third person singular. Yemima explained: “A ‘portion’ can awaken understandings that separate between the omess that creates distance from the sought-for balance. The more she strives to be accurate, the more likely that she will discover the blockages. The mending also mends the body.”²⁵ Her students would write these down as she spoke – often struggling to keep up with her pace, the speed of regular speech – and subsequently use them as a springboard for their own personal reflection, which would also be done in writing and shared with others.

For Yemima, writing was an essential part of the practice, creating a necessary point of distance and reflection, and aiding the cleansing of baggage,²⁶ as well as serving to intensify the impression left by those things written about upon the field of awareness.²⁷ When writing one’s personal understandings of the portion, one is directed to examine one’s heart and being. Sharing such writings with the group leads to rich mutual gain. And when this sharing was done with Yemima herself, it could at times actually trigger other portions to come down to her.²⁸

However, this writing took place for the most part with old-fashioned pen and paper. Due to this, many of these portions remain unpublished. She left behind no written legacy per se;²⁹ but they are recorded in the notebooks of these students who went on to teach others from them. Occasionally, they reflected current events at the time of writing.³⁰ Some of the writings have now made their way onto the internet and Facebook.³¹ Today the Yemima method continues to be taught all over Israel by these students,³² as well as by students of students, using the same technique of dictating Yemima’s portions and then reflecting upon them for their specific personal relevance in the moment. 

Yemima died in 1999 and I jumped on the bandwagon too late to meet her. But circa 2005 I spent a year and a half studying with a student of hers, Sara Schwartz, in the Nahlaot neighborhood of Jerusalem. This study was, as mentioned, life-changing, helping me to find balance and to be intentional in every moment’s “diyuk”. Our job is, I learned, simply to ascertain what the diyuk is, time after time, moment after moment. It was during this time that I grasped, probably for the first time in my life, what it means to have a rebbe: the way I articulated it to myself back then was “there is someone who is so far above you in understanding that all you can do is grab onto their coat-tails and begin to soar.”³³ 

While this experience of discovering a female rebbe for myself stood out as unique for me then, I was, unbeknownst to me, far from being alone in this when it came to Yemima. Many of those in contact her with her viewed her as the female version of the Hasidic tzaddik: the tzadeket.³⁴ It’s not for nothing that Yemima has been called the “Rebbe Nahman of our time.”³⁵ Both Rebbe Nahman and Yemima contributed profound and surprising insights into the workings of the inner world, and transmitted texts with the power to heal overwhelmed or broken souls.³⁶ Miracle stories were also told about her, such as wilted flowers coming back to life in her presence;³⁷ but I knew nothing of that (and, with my anti-groupthink tendencies, better so!). All I knew was the wisdom and insight I experienced, that had the power to cleanse my inner encrustations in a way I had never experienced.

Tsippi Kauffman is an academic and scholar of Hasidism who, prior to her untimely passing in September 2019, was researching the connections between the Hasidic movement and Yemima’s work. She is the author of one of the very few scholarly articles about her, which I have cited extensively in this essay. (A long-time friend, she was also the person who introduced me to the Yemima method in the first place; it is marvelous for me to read her sensitive academic analysis of something that was, for both of us, a meaningful experience that we shared as friends way back when). In the course of her article, Kauffman credits Yemima with founding “a contemporary Hasidic female movement.” She argues that while we could categorize Yemima and her method under the title of “new age” or other contemporary spiritual practices, the correct classification is as a Hasidic approach proper. The criteria Kauffman cites to support her claim are the existence of: (a) a goal of personal redemption; (b) a tzaddik mediator; (c) a method of mediation that conforms to the mystic-magic model; (d) the uniqueness of communal mysticism; and (e) an immanent theology.³⁸ 

Einat Ramon, author of another very helpful article cited here, suggests that what Yemima did was to take Hasidic teachings one step further and to a more pragmatically-oriented approach, employing their language in the daily spiritual discipline (melakhah) of recording personal-emotional observations, and creating her own idiosyncratic language along the way.³⁹ Oded David, a teacher of Yemima’s method, has termed it an “Israeli-kabbalistic creation,” but without further elaboration or explanation.⁴⁰ It should also be noted that not everyone took kindly to her innovation of a new approach with neither Torah precedent, rabbinical chain of tradition, nor approval from gedolei ha-dor.⁴¹Kauffman deliberately terms Yemima’s school of thought a Hasidic-female one (and specifically female, but not feminist).⁴² While Yemima taught men, too – separately from the women – many of whom connected to her teachings and went on to become teachers themselves, the women represented the majority and continue to do so. If Kauffman’s claim is correct, then we can note that in leading a Hasidic spiritual movement as a woman, with chiefly women followers and also some men, Yemima is unique in the Jewish landscape.⁴³ For those who claim that the rise in the feminine augurs messianic times, she represents another step towards global redemption.⁴⁴ This helps to pinpoint, too, how she differed from my other “rebbe”, Nehama Leibowitz, who appealed to both women and men equally, and also led no movement per se – and certainly not a Hasidic one.

The momentum of Yemima’s teaching did not abate after her death. On the contrary, it picked up steam and continues to do so. On Thursday May 30th 2019, I found myself at an event marking her 20th yahrzeit, apparently the first of its kind. I walked into the grounds of a beautiful home in Gimzo, a religious moshav in central Israel. To my left, a barn containing several beautiful horses; to my right, a table selling Yemima paraphernalia (Yemima “merch”! Who knew such a thing existed?). All around me, women milled around, dressed in colorful clothing, many sporting headscarves. Most were dressed in religious women’s clothing, some more modern and some less so, along with a small minority that were dressed in less traditional fashion. Regardless of their religious identification, what is certain is that every one of these women was interested in a path of personal growth, infused with a unique spiritual quality.

After an introduction by our hostess and owner of the lovely house, Edit Shalev, a psychotherapist and Yemima teacher and practitioner, we split off into groups for workshops. The workshop I attended, by Avital Bar-Am, was based on what has apparently become known as the Yemima prayer, a “portion” containing the repeating phrase yehi ratzon, “May it come to pass.” As is typical in Yemima’s writings, the sentences are somewhat obscure and not always grammatically coherent. Here is a snippet, which will also provide a taste of a session studying Yemima’s teaching (my translation is inadequate in conveying the full force of her language): 

May it come to pass that we all merit the genuinely good, in truth.

May it come to pass that your heart shall cease its crying, and you will know happiness in it. 

And that you shall be happy, too, in the profound understanding of existence. 

And that you shall sleep well at night, and arise happy again, and that you will understand differently. 

That you will understand the heart and what occurred and also your parents, to know them well, the good in them and what is not good, if such there is, it is not your business. 

Live your existence. 

Then there will be within you a secure awareness of quiet existence, of whole existence. 

Light that flourishes grows from your deeds.

As with every Yemima class, the teacher initially dictated Yemima’s words and we wrote them down verbatim. We then scrutinized the sentences and attempted to decipher them. Participants were asked for their personal understandings of the phrase “the understanding of existence that goes deep/deepens” (havanat ha-kiyum ha-ma’amik).

Avital then shared what she drew out of this prayer, what she defined as a surefire and accessible recipe for happiness: to do things piece by piece. If we internalize that the world is inherently imperfect, and that our job is simply to engage with those small units of goodness which are in our reach, implementing them steadily act by act, then we will be content in life, for these units are indeed within our grasp. She cited the Baal Shem Tov’s statement (concerning God’s oneness) that when you grasp a part, you have grasped the whole.⁴⁵ She related this to the idea that in doing our work incrementally, we will also be led to a gradual and steady cleansing and purification of our hearts; and hence to much joy. This, for Yemima, is the understanding of the ever-deepening existence and journey of life, which is to be found not in large gestures but in the daily portion of good work. Similarly I recall to this day, after so many years, my own teacher quoting Yemima as saying, “May it be [halevai] that I may carry out my diyuk, like a simple laborer, day by day.” After all, what else is there?

Following this, we heard a few short TED-style talks from different speakers. Tsippi Kauffman noted lines of similarity between the thinking of the Baal Shem Tov and Yemima. Aluma Lev, a popular younger teacher, spoke about the gap between understanding and implementation, between awareness and emotion – likening it to two children on a school hike, with thought being the kid that eagerly runs ahead of the bunch, skipping over rocks, while emotion is the child most often found lagging behind, heavy and awkward. “They don’t even see the same landscape,” she noted poignantly. 

Ilan Haran, one of the few men present, then took the microphone and recounted the beginnings of his relationship with Yemima. At the time secular and successfully working in hi-tech, after Ilan first heard Yemima’s name, both he and his wife were curious. His wife was the first to attend a lesson with Yemima, and responded afterwards to his “Nu?” with the words, “I didn’t understand anything; but it was nice.” The following week she gave a similar report, and seemed to want to continue. At this point, her husband decided to go see for himself. “I pride myself on speaking Hebrew fluently,” he informed us, “but I couldn’t comprehend in the least bit what was being said! Yet there was something special there. At the time I was not familiar with the concept of ‘light,’ but there was light there, so I continued.” 

This journey was ultimately to bring Ilan to religion. He would familiarize himself with, and become part of, the light he had sensed initially but did not understand. This was true for many, though not all, of her students. Yemima was not an outreach (“kiruv”) teacher; she taught tools for improved mental wellbeing and cognitive and emotional functioning, of benefit to all. Yet Kauffman observes that people living according to the method reported feeling bathed in light, experiencing “openness to another dimension of reality, of spiritual life, of revealing the divine spark. They say that by being ‘in their place’ (al mekoman) according to Yemima’s teaching, they encounter ‘The Place’ (Ha-Makom), which means God in the Sages’ language.”⁴⁶ 

Yemima referred to the generation of her students as “the generation of confusion,” indicating that many of the Jewish spiritual values had become blurred during the generation born and raised after the establishment of the State of Israel, with increased polarization of secular and religious extremes.⁴⁷ Her work was clearly an attempt to moderate this ill. 

Today, as noted, thousands of women and men continue to study the Yemima method,⁴⁸ including an entire new generation of millennials, for whose self-reflective/self-improving tendencies and emotional sensitivities the method is very well suited. She is often quoted by those active in the fledgling field of livuy ruhani (pastoral or spiritual care/chaplaincy) in Israel.⁴⁹ Her terminology has actually crept into day-to-day language in certain circles. Devotees of her method include high-profile Israeli celebrities such as Etti Ankri, Avri Gilad, and Shlomo Artzi. Her adherents span the religious spectrum and encompass many types.⁵⁰

However, Yemima’s work has not become known widely in the English-speaking world. There have been attempts to teach it in English, but I believe that they have found only limited success. Ilan Haran reports that, as a fluent English speaker, when he tried to convey Yemima’s portions in English, “the language was transmitted, but none of the light came through with it.” This remark, for me, is convincing evidence of the Yemima method being an authentic manifestation of a specifically Jewish-Israeli wisdom – coming full circle back to the point made in my opening paragraphs: that this is Torah of Zion. And, like the thought of Rabbis Froman and Shagar, her approach did evince broad appeal and universally relevant content.⁵¹

And with this thought about English I will also close. Those Lehrhaus readers who have made it through this entire lengthy article (shkoah), have been intrigued by the glimpse provided here, and wish to study the Yemima method in depth, will not be able to access it meaningfully without Hebrew. Even those fairly fluent in the language will not find it easy to grasp the meaning of her lyrical and somewhat obscure phraseology, and the best thing would be to find a teacher locally or online.⁵² From experience, I can say that when attempting to access Yemima’s mindset, don’t give up too quickly; a bissel patience and humility will get you far. Those who are short on patience and humility will find that immersion in the Yemima method can assist. Remember, it is only your omess getting in the way of your true nature.